Local Pennsylvania Realtors Serving Lancaster & Beyond
Lancaster County PA Real Estate Advisors
Serving Lancaster and Surrounding Counties in PA
EXPERIENCE MAKES THE DIFFERENCE
Trusted Lancaster PA Real Estate Services
Your go-to resource for buying or selling a home in Lancaster, PA. Explore real estate listings and find your perfect home today!
Sell Your Home
Thinking of putting your home up on the market? Learn more about the process and getting started
Work with Experts
We employ the best Lancaster PA real estate agents in order to meet your needs!
Testimonials
Posted on Google Gina PetrickApril 20, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol and her team provided excellent customer service! Carol’s knowledge, patience, and integrity is unmatched. I would definitely recommend Carol Lehman/Hostetter Realty for your real estate buying or selling needs.Posted on Google Ann LaukhuffApril 19, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol is an amazing person. She was so helpful selling my house. I would highly recommend her.Posted on Google Lea RiveraApril 18, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol was exactly the realtor we needed in this tough market! We trusted the reviews and gave her a call once we realized we needed someone well connected and a true expert of the area we were specifically looking to land in (Pequea Valley SD or Conestoga Valley). She did not disappoint! She jumped into action for us on a home we wanted to make an offer on and ensured we were knowledgeable on our offer, it was strong & met our demands with the sellers wishes. In less than 12 hours we found out we got the house! It was quick, seamless & stress free. We can't wait to move into our new home ❤️ Thank you to Carol & the team helping our dreams come true!Posted on Google GMApril 8, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol helped my son buy his first house. Her follow up after the sale was top notch!Posted on Google Kevin FriedelApril 8, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol helped me buy my first home. She made the process easy and less stressful, even helping me negotiate a new roof. The home inspector missed a minor plumbing issue and Hostetter covered it for me.Posted on Google Daniel SkinnerMarch 16, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol was an amazing realtor to work with. She went out of her way to make sure all my needs we met while searching. She made sure the entire home buying experience went as smoothly as possible. 100% would recommend using her!Posted on Google Jesse RohrbaughFebruary 26, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol was amazing to work with! She is so knowledgeable and patient and really takes her time with you to find the best house. As a first time home buyer, she helped me find lenders I could trust to make the closing process as easy as possible.Posted on Google Brittany MyersJanuary 23, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. My husband and I worked with Carol to buy our first home. She was so kind and helpful throughout the whole process! Her experience and organization made everything go so smoothly.Posted on Google Ethan CornwellJanuary 23, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Loved working with Carol all the way through the process of getting our new home!Posted on Google Carson LehmanJanuary 18, 2026Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. My wife and I worked with Carol and her team to purchase 2 homes. Her experience and ability to negotiate is Excellent! She cares deeply for her clients and advises them as she would her own family. We highly recommend working with Carol.
About The Company
Hostetter Realty, Since 1974
Your Boutique Real Estate Local Experts
Hostetter Realty was founded in 1974 by Donald Hostetter in Cochranville, Chester County. What began as a small real estate firm focused on selling farms and homes has grown into a relationship-driven company that remains deeply connected to the local communities it serves. As a boutique real estate firm, Hostetter Realty offers a more personalized, high-touch experience—where clients receive tailored guidance, consistent communication, and trusted advice every step of the way. With a strong emphasis on local expertise, collaboration, and long-term relationships, the firm prioritizes quality over quantity, ensuring each client receives dedicated attention and a customized approach to buying or selling their home.
After the untimely passing of Donald Hostetter in 1980, his daughter, Darlene Byler, stepped in to lead the business. In 1986, Donald’s son, Dwane Hostetter, joined the firm and soon expanded its presence by opening a second office in New Holland. Today, as a proud third-generation company, broker/owner Greg Hostetter, alongside Carol Lehman, leads a team of more than 40 agents across three offices—continuing the legacy of trusted, community-focused real estate service.
Hostetter Realty’s reputation for honesty and integrity is well known. The “Golden Rule” has been the overriding principle for the company since its inception. The business was founded as a family-run operation and has remained so for over 50 years. These family values are consistently maintained and are evident throughout the company. A family atmosphere and team concept is at the heart of Hostetter Realty.
What is your home REALLY worth?
Thinking of selling your house? Click the button below to get an evaluation of your home’s value for free!
Ready to take the Next Step?
Office
321 E Main St New Holland Pa 17557
Contact
717-354-6416 - Office
717-354-HOME - Direct
717-278-9112 - Text
carol@hostetterrealty.com
