Meet Carol Lehman
and the Real Estate Experts at Hostetter Realty
Testimonials
Ryan PendergastAugust 26, 2025Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol and her team pulled off the impossible for us. We had a 2nd child on the way, and were looking to sell, buy, and move with a 4 month deadline of having our 2nd. Carol and team worked to make sure we got every showing appointment we could, listed and negotiated fairly and diligently, and managed to get over asking for sale, under asking for the buy, and we had a 2 month overlap of being able to move out as we transitioned jobs and family. Truly a remarkable experience and so grateful for their work and belief in being able to get us into our dream home. Lauren Rogers-SirinAugust 24, 2025Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol is an excellent realtor. She worked hard to find me my dream home. She helped me find a good mortgage company as well. She gives great advise and I felt that she had my best interests in mind. I highly recommend working with her Josh LewisMay 18, 2025Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. We loved working with Carol. She came recommended from my sister-in-law who had also worked with Carol to get her house. Carol was clear in explaining what to expect from our house buying experience every step of the way and was available if we ever had questions. She's professional and friendly, and gave us great advice for getting the home we wanted. My wife and I would definitely recommend working with her on finding their forever home. Joe SciameJanuary 23, 2025Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol was an exceptional collaborator. She promptly addressed all my inquiries and instilled a profound sense of comfort throughout our working relationship. Thank you again, Joe. Scott UmbleJanuary 16, 2025Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Working with Carol has been a fantastic experience. She goes above and beyond in whatever she's helping me with and brings a happy and positive attitude no matter what the situation is. I highly recommend working with her if you get the chance. Daria ChmylJanuary 10, 2025Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I can't recommend Carol Lehman highly enough for her thorough market insights and outstanding client relations! A top-notch professional who excels in every way! Her unparalleled knowledge and commitment ensure a smooth and successful journey for every client! Zach StrothersJanuary 4, 2025Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I have the pleasure of being in a business group with Carol and it was clear to me when I first met her, that she not only enjoys her work, but is very knowledgeable on the subject as well! If you are looking for a realtor who is professional, great at communication and knowledgeable in her field, contact Carol right away! Duane MartinDecember 31, 2024Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Carol was wonderful to work with, she looked out for our best interest and kept us informed and made buying our rental property a smooth process!
“Carol Lehman has been working with buyers and sellers since 2002. She loves building relationships with her clients and will guide you with the same advice she would recommend for her family and friends. “
OUR SERVICES
Buy or Sell your Home
Whether you are looking to buy or sell your home, our trusted team of experienced Lancaster PA real estate agents are ready to help!
Free Home Evaluation
Thinking of selling your house? Click the button below to get an evaluation of your home's value for free!
About Carol Lehman
Real Estate Agent
Carol Lehman has been working with buyers and sellers since 2002. She loves building relationships with her clients and will guide you with the same advice she would recommend for her family and friends. Given the opportunity you will see her high integrity, honesty, excellence and enthusiasm!
Born and raised in Lancaster County, Carol lives in the eastern part of the county with her husband Chuck. They have 2 married sons that both live in the local area.
In addition to spending time with her family and grandchildren she is involved with Christian Fellowship Church in New Holland and currently serves on the board for Crossnet Ministries in New Holland. When time allows, her and her husband love spending time playing golf and time in the mountains.
Carol would love to meet you and hear about your real estate needs or just to be a resource to answer questions!

Meet the Team
Born and raised in Lancaster County, PA we offer years of knowledge about our hometown. We are passionate about Lancaster and desire to carry on the strong faith and values that it was founded upon.
Combined our team have been meeting the needs of buyer’s and seller’s for 60+ years. We are full-time Lancaster PA real estate agents and would be honored to represent you.
Ready to take the Next Step?
Office
321 E Main St New Holland Pa 17557
Contact
717-354-6416 - Office
717-278-9112 - Cell
carol@hostetterrealty.com
Open Hours
Monday-Friday 8 am - 6pm
Saturday 11am - 4pm